Are We Agile or Just Chaotic?

​

Let’s start with an uncomfortable truth: many engineering managers don't understand "Agile" beyond its buzzwords. Everyone nods along when “scrum” or “sprint” is mentioned, but beneath the veneer of standups and burndown charts lies a messy reality—teams are running fast but often in the wrong direction.

The result? We’ve traded long-term product strategy for short-term deliverables, like burning the furniture to keep warm. Agile promised us the ability to adapt, but what we’ve created is a culture of perpetual urgency where the engineering team’s alignment with the product roadmap is, at best, an afterthought.

The Rise (and Fall?) of Agile

Agile was born out of frustration. Back in 2001, the Agile Manifesto was written as a rallying cry against the rigid and often bloated processes of traditional software development. It emphasized collaboration, flexibility, and delivering value incrementally. Sounds good, right?

Fast forward to today, and Agile has become the gospel of tech teams everywhere. But like any good religion, Agile is now being interpreted in ways that are, frankly, ridiculous. Stakeholders demand features yesterday. Engineering managers juggle resources like they’re in a circus act. Teams adopt Agile ceremonies without understanding the principles, creating a Frankenstein version of the original intent.

Here’s the kicker: most companies are neither agile nor strategic. They’re just busy.

Engineering Teams Are Not "Feature Factories"

​

Your engineering team is not a group of elves working overtime to deliver magical features. Engineering is a strategic function, not just a production line. But in many organizations, engineering managers are forced to operate like factory supervisors, churning out features to hit arbitrary deadlines.

This obsession with velocity is killing real innovation. When every sprint is crammed with tasks, there’s no room for the team to think critically about the product’s strategic importance. Instead of asking, “How does this feature align with our long-term goals?” the focus shifts to, “How fast can we ship it?”

Real agility is about doing the right thing, not just doing the thing right.

The Burndown Chart Fallacy

Let’s talk about burndown charts for a second. You know, those pretty graphs that show how much work your team has “burned down” during a sprint. Here’s the problem: burndown charts are often mistaken for indicators of success.

• A sprint where every task is completed doesn’t mean your team is delivering value.
• It could mean your backlog is full of low-priority fluff that keeps everyone busy but moves the product nowhere.

Burndown charts are like gym selfies: they look great on the surface but don’t tell you whether the work actually matters.

“But Agile Works for Us!”

​

Let’s address the defenders of Agile who might say:

1. “Agile increases collaboration!”

Sure, collaboration is a core tenet of Agile, but ask yourself: Is your team collaborating or just attending endless meetings? When standups devolve into status updates and retrospectives become blame games, you’re not collaborating—you’re wasting time.

2. “Agile makes us faster!”

Faster at what? Speed is meaningless if your team is running in the wrong direction.In fact, poorly executed Agile often leads to rework, which is the opposite of efficiency.

3. “Agile helps us respond to change!”

This one’s partially true. But let’s be real: if your team is constantly pivoting, you’re not agile—you’re indecisive. There’s a fine line between adaptability and chaos.

​

What’s the Alternative?

The solution isn’t to throw Agile out the window. It’s to stop worshiping it like a sacred cow. Agile is a tool, not a strategy. Engineering managers need to focus on the following principles:

1. Strategic Alignment: Tie every sprint, every task, and every feature to the product roadmap. If it doesn’t align, it doesn’t ship.
2. Quality Over Quantity: Measure success by outcomes, not output. A single impactful feature is worth more than a dozen half-baked ones.
3. Empowered Teams: Give your engineers the time and space to think critically. Creativity thrives in environments that aren’t suffocated by deadlines.

Agile Is Like a Highway

​

Think of Agile like a highway. The methodology gives you the lanes, traffic signs, and speed limits to move efficiently. But if you don’t know where you’re going, you’ll just drive in circles.

Stop Misusing Agile

​

Agile isn’t broken; we are. When misused, Agile becomes a crutch that enables bad habits: poor planning, weak alignment, and a focus on activity over results.

Engineering managers, stop being “project managers with coding knowledge.” Your job is to connect the dots between product vision and technical execution. That means saying no to unnecessary tasks, asking hard questions, and always steering your team toward strategic outcomes.

Recommended Reading

Want to dive deeper into these ideas? Check out these highly rated books:

1. ​The Lean Startup by Eric Ries: Learn how to adapt and innovate in fast-paced environments.
2. ​The Goal by Eliyahu M. Goldratt: Understand bottlenecks and optimize your team’s processes.
3. ​User Story Mapping by Jeff Patton: Improve collaboration and prioritize features effectively.

Final Thought

Agile isn’t about doing things faster—it’s about doing the right things better. Let’s stop pretending otherwise.
​
​